The difference between a large cantata and a small oratorio is hard to determine, but normally a cantata uses smaller, more various forces, attempts to fill a smaller dramatic canvas, and admits a much wider latitude in form.
It has been asserted that Alexis Contant's Caïn (1905, and premiered that year) was the first Canadian oratorio. Though it probably was the largest and most imposing work of its kind to have been produced at that time, it in fact was preceded by Frantz Jehin-Prume's Oratorio dédié à Léon XIII (1886; no record of performance), Eva Rose York's David and Jonathan (performed twice in 1887 in Belleville, Ont), and Hugh Clarke's Jerusalem (Presser 1890; composed in Philadelphia). Other early oratorios include Napoléon Crépault's La Communion des saints (performed in Quebec City ca 1880) and Roberta Geddes-Harvey's Salvator. Invoke Her Name with Praise, a 45-minute oratorio by Cyril C. O'Brien, had its premiere in Halifax, NS, in 1940.
After 1950 some Canadians have produced hybrid works which combine elements of oratorio with elements of other genres, eg, Ridout in his 'dramatic symphony' Esther (1952, premiered that year at the RCMT under Ettore Mazzoleni), Paul McIntyre in his 'melodrama-cantata' Judith (1958, premiered in 1959 at the Vancouver International Festival, with Lois Marshall in the solo role), Leon Zuckert in his 'choreographic oratorio' In the Gleam of Northern Lights (1974, commissioned by the Shevchenko Musical Ensemble), and Anhalt in his 'musical tableau in seven sections on the life of Marie de l'Incarnation,' La Tourangelle (1975, premiered that year in Toronto by the sopranos Mary Morrison and Roxolana Roslak, the mezzo-soprano Phyllis Mailing, the tenor Albert Greer, the baritone Gary Relyea, and the CBC Festival Orchestra and Choir under Marius Constant).
Among the numerous cantatas, near-oratorios, quasi-oratorios, and oratorio hybrids, the list of clear examples of the genre seems short. The ensuing one, alphabetical by composer, attempts to be representative but cannot claim to be complete.
Bissell, Keith The Passion According to St Luke (St Luke's gospel, Wilde, Donne, Bridges, Heber, and the Sussex Mummers' Carol). 1970 (Toronto 1971 under the direction of the composer). Waterloo 1973
Boucher, Lydia L'Oeuvre d'Esther Blondin. 1949
Chotem, Neil The Song of Solomon, radio oratorio. 1951. RCI 85 (CBC Montreal orchestra and chorus conducted by Chotem)
Clarke, F.R.C. Bel and the Dragon (apocryphal book of the same name). 1954. A doctoral exercise for the University of Toronto
Clarke, Hugh Jerusalem (the Scriptures). Presser 1890
Contant, Alexis Caïn (Brother Symphorien-Louis). 1904-5 (Montreal 1905)
- Les Deux Âmes (Henri Roullaud). 1906?-09 (Montreal 1913)
Crépault, Napoléon La Communion des saints. ca 1880 (Quebec City ?)
Geddes-Harvey, Roberta Salvator (scripture, with verses by Neale, Havergal, Gerhardt, Milton, Klugh, Heber, and Montgomery). ca 1906 (Guelph 1907?). Published by C.W. Thompson, Boston 1907. Later performed again in Guelph (in 1912) and in Toronto and Kingston
Higgin, Clifford Calvary. ? (London, under Sir Henry Wood). Breitkopf & Härtel
Horner, Ralph David's First Victory
- St Peter
Jehin-Prume, Frantz Oratorio dédié à Léon XIII. 1886
Kenins, Talivaldis Daniel. 1965. Private publication
Kunz, Alfred The Big Land. 1967
- The Creation (Laurence Cummings). 1972
Lamoureux, Alfred La Tragédie d'Esther
- La Samaritaine
Lemieux, J.-L. Les Prémices or Les Saints Martyrs canadiens, libretto by Arthur Charlebois, a teacher of Lemieux (Brother Barnabé) and himself an oratorio composer. 1947
Milette, Juliette Leur Maison. 1944 (Montreal 1944). Written for the centennial of the founding of the Canadian religious order of the Holy Names of Jesus and Mary
O'Brien, Cyril C. Invoke Her Name with Praise. 1940
Pedersen, Paul Passion Oratorio. 1990 rev of Cantata and Narrative for Good Friday (1961, rev 1970)
Poynter, A. The Great Commission (Poynter, incorporating quotations from scripture). 1963
Reeves, John Salvator Mundi, liturgical drama (Biblical and liturgical sources). 1983 (Toronto 1983)
Talbot, Robert Évangéline
Telfer, Nancy The Journey. 1982 (Thunder Bay, Ont 1982). Premiered for Women's Inter-Church Council by mezzo-soprano Catherine Robbin, the Thunder Bay Symphony Orchestra and Chorus, conducted by Dwight Bennett; also performed for World Council of Churches, Vancouver, 1983. Thompson 1982
Wilson, Charles The Angels of the Earth (Wilson MacDonald). 1966 (Guelph, Ont 1967). Premiered by soprano Mary Morrison and baritone James Bechtel, with the Bach-Elgar Choir of Hamilton, under the composer's direction
York, Eva Rose David and Jonathan; 1887