- John Holland
- John Honsberger (Primary Source)
- John J. Doyle
- John J. Walkty
- John "Jake" Pope Beer (Primary Source)
- John James Jack Charlwood
- John James Thompson
- John Joseph "Joe" Currie
- John Joseph Reid "Johnny" Barron
- John Joseph White
- John "Kevin" Power (Primary Source)
- John Kilpatrick
- John Kolanchey (Primary Source)
- John Kubis
- John Kyle Beach
